“Theories about what causes colic–a baby’s underdeveloped nervous system, underdeveloped digestive tract, milk protein intolerance, swallowed air–are as varied as treatments (heating pads, antigas medicine, enemas, hypoallergenic formulas, vibrating cribs, baby holding methods, white noise). While there is no consensus on what causes colic, a number of researchers and pediatric gastroenterologists are beginning to see colic as a normal part of early development combined with a sensitive temperament rather than an abnormality or a sign of pain.” – Los Angeles Times article “Colic May Just be a Normal Part of Baby’s Development” by Kathleen Kelleher
I’m sharing the following information on colic with you so you won’t be caught off guard like I was. Again, knowledge is power. Ignorance is what causes fear and anxiety, which in turn can contribute toward postpartum depression (PPD) when you’re exhausted from not lining up resources in advance to provide support so you don’t get too exhausted.
Lack of awareness of what colic is will only cause first-time parents who happen to have a baby with colic fear that something is terribly wrong with their baby. It’s through educating, anticipating and preparing for the possibility of such things as colic—among other things such as cradle cap, eczema, reflux, allergies to milk, and the startle response—that would empower expectant parents (before their babies are born) with knowledge, thereby removing fear from the equation. Preventing stress/anxiety that comes from not knowing what is going on and how to address such developments can make a huge difference in one’s first-time experience at parenting. What the parents with a colicky baby must realize is that they did not cause the colic to occur. There are many babies out there—more than you know—that are colicky. In fact, it is one of the most frequent problems presented to pediatricians in the first 3 months of an infant’s life, with an occurrence rate of 10-20% of infants between the ages of 2 weeks and 4 months.
The first three months of an infant’s life are almost like a fourth trimester spent outside the mother’s womb trying to adapt to the real world, the world outside mom’s belly. At this point, infants are still not fully developed. In most cases, infants don’t sleep through the night until their 3rd month or later. It is considered normal development for infants to be fussy and cry more often during the first three months. Unfortunately, for some parents, colic strikes in some infants sometime in those first three months.
A Los Angeles Times article “Colic May Just be a Normal Part of Baby’s Development” by Kathleen Kelleher points out these good-to-know statistics: “Research conducted by guru pediatrician T. Berry Brazelton established that healthy babies, regardless of temperament, cry more in the first four months of life. Crying peaks at 6 weeks to an average of 3-1/2 hours a day but declines at about 3 months to about an hour and 20 minutes, where it stabilizes for the first year of life. Crying declines at 3 months, Brazelton and other pediatricians postulate, because as a baby matures developmentally, she is better able to communicate her needs to parents and better able to soothe herself (by finding a pacifier or thumb).”
One of the most difficult and stressful experiences parents may experience at some point during the first three months of their baby’s life, colic is very intense/excessive crying in an otherwise healthy infant that usually begins in the late afternoon/early evening and continues inconsolably for at least 3 hours.
Usual signs/symptoms of a baby with colic…while screaming/crying, the infant’s:
- face is red and grimacing
- fists are clenched
- legs are pulled up over the abdomen
- back is arched
A Parents.com article “How Much Crying Is Normal?” by Grace Monfort points out that “Even among the medical community, colic is less a condition than a classification, defined by the rule of threes: inconsolable crying that begins and ends for no apparent reason, lasts at least three hours, occurs on at least three days a week, and continues for at least three weeks but seldom more than three months. By that definition, some 16 to 26 percent of infants are categorized as colicky.” Wessel et al (Pediatrics 1954;14:421-435 Paroxysmal fussing in infancy, sometimes called colic) originated what is still the most commonly accepted definition of colic, which is based on the “rule of three [or] crying for more than three hours per day, for more than three days per week, and for more than three weeks in an infant that is well-fed and otherwise healthy.”
Even after 50 years of research, no one is really sure what causes colic. The exact cause of colic is unknown but per The Fussy Baby Site, the baby’s temperament, state control (i.e., how well your baby transitions from sleep to awake, how easily they can calm themselves, etc.), stimulation in the environment, and stress in the home are contributing factors. Though colic has been attributed to gastrointestinal issues (e.g., gas pain, acid reflux, sensitivity/allergy/lactose intolerance to milk), immature nervous system, and psychocial issues (e.g., temperament, maternal anxiety/depression, anxiety/depression of the woman during pregnancy), less than 5% of babies show evidence of a physical/medical problem that would explain the crying, according to research by Dr. Ronald Barr, professor of pediatrics and psychiatry at McGill University, Quebec (Pediatrics 1998;102(5 suppl E):1282-1286). NOTE: Temperament is described by The Fussy Baby Site as spirited or high needs (e.g., hypersensitive). Per a Los Angeles Times article “Colic May Just be a Normal Part of Baby’s Development” by Kathleen Kelleher, Brazelton believed these babies “are more likely to blow off stress from a full day of environmental stimuli with a good cry.”
It’s easy to see how, since the baby appears to be in pain, the usual signs of colic have led many a person to believe that there might be a digestive issue at hand. Dr. Barr pointed out that, since most infants outgrow colic by four months of age , an immature nervous system rather than digestive issue must be the culprit behind colic. Colic may even be for some babies a part of normal emotional development and the result of not yet being able to regulate crying duration, soothe/calm themselves, cope with change and transitioning from one state to another (e.g., low stimulation to high stimulation, being awake to falling asleep). Until the fourth month or so, crying is the way these babies cope with change. Other possible causes include size at birth relative to gestational age, which may be due to a small placenta, which may be due to the mother failing to take in adequate nutrition during her pregnancy—as in my case wherein I was constantly nauseous from the very beginning to the very end of my pregnancy, and my daughter was born two weeks pre-term and weighing in at 5 pounds 11 ounces.
Nevertheless, a pediatrician should be consulted to rule out any potential illnesses or medical causes. Parents should expect the pediatrician to ask about the baby’s behavior, including when crying episodes begin and how long they last. Parents will need to be able to indicate how often and how much the baby spits up in order to rule out acid reflux. Our pediatrician did mention the possibility that the colic could be caused in reaction to the baby having a tough time adjusting to her environment and overstimulation in terms of sights and sounds and suggested decreasing exposure to noise and interaction is what the baby needed after what is, for an infant, a long day. She explained that our daughter’s colic could be due to her still-immature and developing nervous system, her temperament, or digestive issues.
Since no one really knows what causes colic in the otherwise well-fed, changed baby, there is no real cure for colic as of yet. The following are suggested by some doctors that may or may not improve matters:
- Colic hold – place baby face down along your forearm with inside elbow supporting her head and hand supporting baby’s pelvis (doing this puts gentle pressure on baby’s tummy) while gently rubbing baby’s back with other hand
- Bicycling legs – Gently press his legs up to his chest, one at a time, in a peddling type movement.
- Rubbing tummy gently
- Apply warm compress on tummy
- Simulating the womb experiences (baby spent so much time in the mother’s womb but, once born, we expect that they can adjust to being left in a quiet room to sleep, laying flat):
- Create motion via carrying in a sling, rocking (in arms while shushing, infant swing, or car seat), bouncing (in car seat on drying machine, driving around), swaying, or dancing
- Generate white noise via shushing, setting baby in car seat on drying machine, white noise machine
- Swaddle
- Pediatric chiropractic care (make sure the chiropractor treats infants) – more info on this here
- Infant probiotic drops (e.g., L. Reuteri Probiotics) or gas drops (e.g., Mylicon)*
- Herbal teas, like chamomile
- If breastfeeding, try formula (consulting with pediatrician about whether or when you should try a hypo-allergenic or soy formula) or try eliminating caffeine, dairy, eggs, nuts, certain vegetables and even wheat products from your diet.
For other products or suggestions for soothing colic, click here and here.
* The Fussy Baby Site mentions research in the treatment of colic using L. Reuteri Probiotics versus Simethicone (the active ingredient in Mylicon gas drops) where 95% of the babies treated with L. Reuteri probiotics showed improvement, while only 7% of the babies treated with gas drops showed improvement.
It goes without saying that a baby that cries inconsolably, who cries so hard that his body distorts, can cause parents to feel alarmed and fear that there is something seriously wrong with the baby. Despite trying every possible means of trying to calm the baby, the baby can cry for hours on end everyday for days and sometimes weeks or months. Regardless, it’s easy to understand how mothers of colicky infants—or infants who cry and cannot be consoled for three hours or more a day at least three days a week starting from when they are three to six weeks old up until they are three months old and are otherwise healthy—would experience feelings of guilt, anxiety, frustration, desperation, helplessness and hopelessness—not to mention an utter failure—for not being able to find a way to console her baby and especially since the infant looks like it’s in pain while crying to intensely. Don’t be too hard on yourself for feeling occasionally frustrated and near wit’s end during times of endless crying. Several days of sleep deprivation and/or a baby crying inconsolably for hours can make practically anyone deprived of sleep for several days straight—even fathers and mothers who don’t have PPD—feel like they’re going crazy and join their babies in crying/screaming themselves.
Studies have shown a link between colic and depression. Whether colic contributes to PPD or PPD contributes to infantile colic is yet to be definitively determined. As a parent, you think you’re supposed to not only be able to know what your baby wants and needs, but also how to fix the problem. After a few days of crying with seemingly no end in sight, at her wits end with anxiety and exhaustion, the new mom and/or dad may slip into depression. They say that babies can sense their parents’ anxiety, so they only cry harder, louder and longer, which is all the more painful for the parents to bear. And so on and so forth, a vicious cycle.
In addition to a link with depression, colic can put a huge dent in the confidence of both parents in terms of their ability to care for their baby. Due to the process of elimination to determine an underlying cause of colic, mothers end up weaning earlier and possibly even changing formulas multiple times. With colic, there is unfortunately also an increased risk for shaken baby syndrome.
If you feel like you’re having trouble coping, the best thing you can do for yourself and your family is to ask for some help. Make sure you have enough support lined up to take over when necessary during this time. Whenever you feel the onset of any of the above-mentioned emotions, have someone else watch your baby for a little while so you can get a break. Consider hiring a postpartum doula, who is experienced with colicky babies. If no one is around at the time, put the baby down in the crib and go another room to take 5 minutes to calm down and take a few deep breaths. You are allowed (and it’s important) to take a break. It’s the best thing you can do for yourself and to retain your mental wellbeing!